Picking a smartwatch feels impossible lately. Dozens of options all promise the world—advanced health tracking, military-grade durability, week-long battery life—and most of it turns out to be marketing fluff. I’ve been testing fitness-focused smartwatches for the past few months, running them through real workouts, sleeping in them, and actually living with each one as my everyday watch. Here’s what holds up.
I wore each watch as my primary device for at least two weeks. That’s the only way to know if health metrics actually matter in daily life or just look pretty in screenshots.
Heart rate accuracy: I compared each watch against a chest strap monitor during runs, cycling sessions, and HIIT workouts. Most optical sensors drift during high-intensity exercise, but some handle it better than others.
Sleep tracking: I logged sleep data against my own patterns and cross-referenced with what the devices reported. Some watches invent sleep stages that never happened.
Battery life: I ran standardized tests with always-on display, continuous heart rate tracking, and one-hour GPS workouts daily. Then I compared that to how long each actually lasted on a real weekend.
Companion apps: The hardware only matters if the software doesn’t suck. I spent time in each company’s app, checking whether data was easy to find or buried in menus I’d never open twice.
The Series 9 is still the one to beat if you want everything in one package. Apple has poured money into health sensors for years, and it shows. This is the most complete health-tracking experience you can get without special medical devices.
What actually works: The S9 chip processes health data on-device, which means heart rate responds faster and the double-tap gesture works even when your hands are full. The ECG app is FDA-cleared and produces readings you can actually send to your doctor. Blood oxygen monitoring returned after a brief absence, and sleep tracking now breaks down REM, core, and deep sleep—it’s actually useful now.
The downside: You’ll charge this every day or two. The always-on display burns battery faster than competitors, and if you’re used to charging weekly, this is a genuine adjustment. Also, it only works with iPhones, so Android users need not apply.
Fitness features: Activity Rings give you motivation without being annoying, and the Workout app covers over 100 exercise types. The depth gauge works for swimming, but if you’re serious about diving, get a proper dive computer.
Price: $399 for the 45mm GPS model. It’s expensive, but you’re paying for the ecosystem as much as the hardware.
If you’re on Android, this is the most complete health package you can get. Samsung has steadily improved its health monitoring, and the Galaxy Watch 6 represents real progress.
Health tracking: The BioActive sensor combines optical heart rate, electrical heart signals, and body composition analysis in one module. It measures blood pressure (after you calibrate it with a cuff—a hassle, but it works), ECG, and estimates skeletal muscle mass and body fat. The heart rate monitor stayed accurate even in cold weather where other watches struggled.
Sleep tracking: Samsung’s Sleep Insights actually helped me. Beyond basic duration, I got scores on sleep efficiency, how long it took to fall asleep, and recovery metrics. The morning summary compared my sleep to people my age, which is either comforting or depressing depending on the night.
Tizen vs. Wear OS: It runs Wear OS 4 now, which means better app support than older Samsung watches while keeping Samsung’s cleaner interface. Battery comfortably lasts two days with always-on display.
Watch out for: Blood pressure monitoring requires regional certification—you can’t just turn it on everywhere. Body composition is an estimate, not a medical measurement. And the circular display is a matter of preference; I find it less readable for data than square screens.
Garmin owns the athletic smartwatch market, and the Forerunner 965 proves why. This is for people training for marathons, triathlons, or anyone who actually cares about training load and recovery.
What makes it special: Training readiness score tells you whether you’re actually ready to push hard or should take a rest day—it combines sleep, recovery time, and recent workout intensity into one number. Race predictor estimates your finish times based on training history, and recovery time tells you how long to wait before the next hard session.
GPS performance: Multi-band GPS tracks accurately even in dense urban areas or under heavy tree cover. I took this on trail runs where other watches added random distance, and it stayed solid.
Battery life: Twelve to fourteen days in smartwatch mode. Twenty-plus hours with GPS and music running. You can do a full Ironman without charging. That’s genuinely impressive.
Who shouldn’t buy it: Casual fitness users will find the metrics overwhelming. If you just want step counts and heart rate, this is overkill.
Not everyone needs a $400 watch. The Charge 6 shows that solid health tracking doesn’t require spending flagship money.
What you get: Bright AMOLED display, continuous heart rate, SpO2 sensor, and built-in GPS. Step counting is accurate, sleep tracking has improved significantly over previous generations, and active zone minutes give you something to aim for beyond raw step counts.
Google integration: You now get Google Maps navigation and YouTube Music controls—Fitbit fixed the smart feature complaints from older models. Google Wallet works for contactless payments.
Battery: Seven days easily. With built-in GPS. That’s rare at this price.
Trade-offs: No always-on display. The band design limits customization. Notifications show basic alerts but you can’t respond richly. These are fine compromises at $159.
Premium consideration: Fitbit’s Premium subscription adds deeper analytics and daily readiness scores. The free features are enough for most people, but health optimizers might want it.
The Instinct 2 Solar is the watch for people who hate charging and treat their gear roughly.
The battery: Solar charging built into the display. In my testing with moderate sunlight, I went over 40 days without plugging in. Turn on GPS and it drops to 30+ hours—which is still more than enough for most backcountry trips. Most people will charge this a few times a year, not weekly.
Build quality: 100 meters water resistance. MIL-STD-810G certified for thermal, shock, and water resistance. The fiber-reinforced polymer case survives drops that would kill other watches. This thing is nearly indestructible.
Health tracking: Full Garmin suite—heart rate, Pulse Ox, stress tracking, sleep analysis, and Body Battery (which combines multiple metrics into an energy score telling you when to push or rest).
What’s missing: No message replies. No app installation. It’s a fitness tracker, not a smartphone replacement. But that simplicity appeals to people tired of digital clutter.
Apple’s second Ultra is bigger, louder, and lasts longer than the regular Apple Watch. It’s for athletes doing genuinely extreme things.
Battery: Thirty-six hours normally, extendable to 72 in low-power mode. It’s not as long as Garmin’s top sports watches, but it’s a huge improvement over standard Apple Watch.
Unique features: Depth gauge works to 40 meters with automatic dive logging. Second speaker enables a Siren loud enough to be heard at distance. The customizable action button lets you start workouts instantly without menu-diving.
Price: $799. That’s a lot. Only get this if you genuinely need the durability, battery, and action button—otherwise the Series 9 does almost everything for half the price.
| Feature | Apple Watch Series 9 | Samsung Galaxy Watch 6 | Garmin Forerunner 965 | Fitbit Charge 6 | Garmin Instinct 2 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Heart Rate | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| ECG | Yes | Yes | No | No | No |
| SpO2 | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Sleep Tracking | Advanced | Advanced | Advanced | Good | Good |
| Blood Pressure | No | Yes* | No | No | No |
| GPS | Built-in | Built-in | Multi-band | Built-in | Built-in |
| Battery Life | 2 days | 2 days | 12-14 days | 7 days | 40+ days |
| Price | $399 | $329 | $599 | $159 | $399 |
*Requires calibration
Heart rate and HRV: Continuous heart rate tracks your pulse all day and during workouts. HRV (heart rate variability) measures the variation between beats—it’s a window into your nervous system and recovery. Low HRV often means your body needs rest.
SpO2: Blood oxygen saturation. Useful for catching breathing issues during sleep or checking how you’re handling high altitude. Most people don’t need constant monitoring, but if you have respiratory conditions, it’s valuable.
ECG: Detects atrial fibrillation and other rhythm issues. It’s not a medical diagnosis tool, but it can catch problems worth mentioning to your doctor.
Sleep tracking: These algorithms classify sleep stages, but they’re estimates. Single nights vary wildly—look at trends over weeks, not individual data points.
Stress tracking: Uses HRV and other sensors to estimate mental tension throughout the day. It works better when you log context (work deadline, argument with spouse) so you learn what actually affects your readings.
Most people: Apple Watch Series 9. Best overall health tracking in a polished package. Tight Apple Health integration makes all your data live in one place.
Android users: Galaxy Watch 6 if you want blood pressure and body composition. Otherwise, pick based on whether you prefer Samsung’s interface or Google’s ecosystem.
Serious athletes: Garmin Forerunner 965. Training load, recovery recommendations, and race predictions are in a different league. The battery lasts for actual ultra events.
Budget buyers: Fitbit Charge 6. Reliable basics at a third the flagship price.
Outdoor adventurers: Garmin Instinct 2 Solar. Charge it a few times a year, beat it up, it keeps working.
Here’s the honest answer: they’re good enough for fitness, not good enough for medicine.
Heart rate: Most optical sensors stay within 5% of chest straps during steady exercise. Accuracy drops during high-movement activities. For general fitness, it’s fine. If you need clinical precision, get a medical device.
Sleep: They estimate total sleep time reasonably well. Sleep stage classification? Not so much. They’re accurate enough for trends but not for diagnosing sleep disorders.
ECG and blood pressure: ECG features have shown reasonable accuracy for catching atrial fibrillation in studies. Blood pressure measurements need validation against traditional cuffs and vary significantly.
Bottom line: Smartwatches are great for tracking trends and spotting patterns worth discussing with your doctor. They’re not replacements for medical care. If you have existing conditions, talk to your physician about what kind of monitoring makes sense for you.
The “best” smartwatch depends entirely on what you actually need. The Apple Watch Series 9 remains the safest recommendation—solid health tracking, polished software, and a massive app ecosystem. Android users get a similarly complete experience with Samsung’s Galaxy Watch 6. Athletes should look at Garmin, budget buyers should look at Fitbit, and anyone who hates charging should look at the Instinct 2 Solar.
Whichever you choose, the real value comes from wearing it consistently. The best watch is the one you’ll actually keep on your wrist, tracking your health over months and years. Set reasonable expectations, check your data regularly, and talk to your doctor about anything concerning.
Choosing the right smartwatch becomes more important as we age. Seniors need devices that combine…
Picking a smartwatch for fitness isn't about grabbing whatever's most popular or looks coolest in…
A good smartwatch won't fix your training, but it can make tracking it less of…
Finding a quality fitness smartwatch without spending a fortune is harder than it should be.…
The best smartwatch for fitness under $200 in 2025 is the Garmin Vívoactive 5. It…
Finding a quality fitness smartwatch without spending a fortune can feel like searching for a…